By now, I've built 8 frames. There is no doubt I am getting better at this, but lets be clear... this is hard. I have focused on building lugged road frames, and have built most of them in very similar ways. I feel frame building is a hard enough endeavor without changing too many variables with each try. The classic road bike is what I'd like to ride, so I've started there. I hope to do some fillet brazing on future bikes and branch out into more diverse styles. I will run down each of the frames I have made below. I talk about straightness in my frames below, and it's important to clarify what I mean. Ideally, the front and rear wheels are in perfect alignment. To achieve this most builders work on getting the head tube and seat tube in line with each other. Then, if you build it right the rear wheel will fall into place. So while brazing, builders strive to get the head tube and seat tube in line without any twist. A twist of 1mm. at points about 15" apart on the head tube is crooked.
#1 I made with the standard road tube set and lugs offered by Nova. This was the cheapest way to get started and I'm glad I did it this way. .9/.6/.9 tubes and round/oval/round chainstays, short campy drop-outs, a flat fork crown and raked blades. I built it from a drawing with as close as I could get to 73°/73° angles and a rake of about 45mm. I say "as close as, and about" because without jigs there was no way of knowing exactly what I was getting. I used a vice, straight edges and my drawing. Painted white with yellow decals this bike rode pretty nice. It's hanging in the corner of my garage and I hope to never let it go.
#2 I wanted to up the ante with my second frame and used better materials, but the same methods. Dedacciai butted Zero Uno oversize tubes, Sachs lugs, drop-outs, and bottom bracket, raked blades with a sachs crown. This frame looked beautiful, and I had it painted professionally a bright green metallic. I especially liked my seat stay caps on this one with the thin tapered seat stays I used. Too bad I didn't like how it rode! I'm not sure what it was, but somehow it must have had very low trail. I couldn't wait to get my next one going. I later put it on my table and realized it went downhill, then uphill, and back again. Mind you, this is only about 2mm, but you have to be pretty close or you'll know it riding. This frame is also hanging in the corner of my shop.
#3 My third frame was built with Columbus Life .7/.4/.7 tubes, and the mini slant 6 lugs Darrell McCulloch designed. I used slotted drop-outs and a straight fork built with a stainless Long Shen crown. The bottom bracket was a Pacenti and I used 14 mm double taper seat stays with a stainless cap. I cut little stars out of each lug and the bottom bracket. This was all the good stuff! I still didn't have a jig, but I had my small granite surface to measure with, and it helped. This frame came out very straight except for the bottom bracket which was off slightly. No twist, but the BB shell is slightly canted. I can't notice riding, so it is still my go to bike for riding. I rode it most of last summer without any paint on it and finally painted it blue with gray panels last fall. With Centaur and Mavic Reflex tubulars it weighed in at 18.2lbs. This frame kind of scared me at first because I realized I brazed very light tubes with short butts into it. After riding it a bunch I like the way it feels and am not worried about it. I also feel this frame was the closest I'd gotten to my drawing. I'm about to get ready to go out for a ride, and this is the frame I'll get on...
#4 I modeled #4 after #3. Same tubes, same lugs, same forks. The difference is I used stainless lugs and built in a huge amount of trail. I used my Bringheli jig for this one and it came out pretty nice. A little bit of twist, but really close. The bling of the stainless is nice, and I'd be riding it except I really prefer the trail of #3. It's a pretty bike that I put a ton of time into. I may make a new fork for it someday...
#5 was project "King." This one was for David and we built it together in about a week over xmas break. It's Zero Uno tubing and doesn't have fancy lugs. The fork crown is stainless and it has straight blades. It's sized for David and rides pretty well on the streets of Chicago. I painted it blue metallic with gray panels. It's pretty straight, but not perfect. Just enough off to kind make me mad! But overall pretty good.
#6 I built for myself using Zero Uno. I wanted to knock one out, but ended up spending serious time carving the Pacenti Artisan lugs down. It's a very traditional bike with raked blades and a straight top tube. I painted it dark green and like "King" it is very close to straight. Actually, maybe off more than "King." The fork is a bit short and I don't like that. I may throw another fork on it and I'm sure I'll like it more.
#7 This is a WSD specific design for Susan. I built it with Zero Uno and Pacenti Artisan lugs. A nicely raked fork of 50mm to compliment the 72.5° head tube. 74° seat tube, and really straight. I also dropped the bottom bracket to 80mm. Probably the straightest frame I've made so far.
#8 I just finished this one up and it's also very straight. Lightweight Zero tubing, Sachs lugs, Pacenti stainless crown and bottom bracket. This frame should be my main ride after it's painted. It's made for me with 73°/73°, 45mm rake, 80mm bottom bracket drop, 420mm chainstays.
I know I've left a lot of details out in the descriptions above, but if you look back in my blog, it's all there. More later...